flag Ukraine Stand with Ukraine
ApriorIT

Modern IT products often have to handle various file formats. And while it’s quite easy to ensure compatibility with open file formats, making your software process proprietary or closed file formats is tricky.

The main challenge is that there’s no one-size-fits-all solution for reversing a proprietary file format. In every case, you have to act differently depending on the data you have at hand.

In this article, we explore what a proprietary file format is and why you might need to reverse engineer one. We also share our experience working with files in closed formats and show a few approaches to restoring data from them. This article will be useful for development leaders who want to enhance their product’s interoperability by supporting closed file formats.

Contents:

The hows and whys of reversing files in a proprietary format

    How to determine a proprietary file format based on the file signature

    How to reverse engineer the data format using an executable file

    How to reverse engineer a data format without an executable file

Conclusion

The hows and whys of reversing files in a proprietary format

A file format has a certain encoding scheme for structuring and storing data. A proprietary file format usually can’t be decoded and interpreted without particular software or hardware. Data is usually read and saved in a proprietary format by proprietary software.

A proprietary format is often designed to be secret, meaning that the specification of the data encoding format is not publicly released or is only disclosed under non-disclosure agreements. Sometimes, a creator (an individual developer or an organization) publishes encoding details but restricts a format’s use through licenses. Thus, a proprietary format is considered a closed format in contrast to open formats that are published and can be used by everybody free of charge.

Well-known examples of closed file formats are WMA and CDR. Some popular file formats such as XLS and DOC used to be closed and undocumented but are now open.

Why would you need to reverse engineer a proprietary file format?

Software developers often need to reverse engineer a proprietary file format to improve software interoperability.

Legal positions on handling closed file formats differ according to each country’s laws related to software patents. However, reverse engineering of file formats for improving interoperability is generally legal. Also, you might need to reverse engineer a closed file format for computer forensics.

There’s no general approach to reverse engineering a closed file format that works every time. Each case is individual. In this article, we explore three examples of restoring a proprietary file format for different cases:

3 ways to determine a proprietary file format

Let’s explore each scenario in detail, starting with the one in which we can avoid reverse engineering.

Related services

Professional Reverse Engineering

How to determine a proprietary file format based on the file signature

Work with any file format starts with discovering the format’s name and finding a parser that can work with it. Sometimes, this process can be straightforward and you can find a relevant parser by simply typing <file extension> parser in Google.

However, a file extension sometimes doesn’t match the file’s real format. For example, computer games often specify their resource file extensions as DAT, although inside they can be ZIP files. Also, some video formats based on the Matroska container use a custom codec for streaming videos, and therefore they have non-standard file extensions.

To determine the file format, you can use specialized tools such as:

  • file(1) — a tool for determining file types in Linux
  • Binwalk — a tool for analyzing, reverse engineering, and extracting firmware images
  • FACT extractor — a tool for extracting most common container formats

Read also:
Discovering and Mitigating Security Vulnerabilities in Routers: A Practical Guide

Then, you need to check whether a file is archived and encrypted. A way to do this is by using the Data Visualizer feature in Hex Workshop.

If a file is likely to be archived, try opening it with 7-Zip. Surprisingly, this file archiver can identify formats by scanning the beginning of the file. Even if a file has some custom header before ZIP data, 7-Zip still can identify it.

Another helpful tool is Offzip, which allows you to search for zlib streams in binary code and extract them as files.

All these tools provide an opportunity to identify known file formats and avoid reverse engineering without an actual need. But if you fail to find the file format, you can try to search for it using the file’s signature. To discover the file’s signature, open your file in a hex editor.

A file signature, also known as a magic number, is a unique sequence of bytes at the beginning of the file that’s used to identify its format. Usually, the file signature refers to the first two to eight bytes of a file. Once you have a file’s signature, search for magic numbers on Google and GitHub, using different variants of how these digits can be described on websites or in code.

Say your file’s signature starts with the following bytes: 41 50 52 34 65 76 65 72. Here are a few examples of search requests you should try:

  • 41 50 52 34 65 76 65 72 signature
  • 41 50 52 34 65 76 65 72 magic
  • 41 50 52 34 signature
  • 41 50 52 34 magic
  • 41505234 (because the signature can also be a DWORD)
  • 0x41 0x50 0x52 0x34 0x65 0x76 0x65 0x72 signature
  • 0x41505234
  • 0x34525041 (in case it’s little-endian)
  • You can also use American Standard Code for Information Interchange (ASCII). In our case, our search query for the file signature will look like “APR4ever.”

Such an approach can help you identify what this file format is similar to or even find a ready-to-use parser. You can also find other files in such a format and analyze who created them and how they can be parsed.

Read also:
How to Reverse Engineer Software (Windows) the Right Way

How to reverse engineer the data format using an executable file

If you didn’t manage to find something after thoroughly searching for a file signature on Google, it can mean that your file format is indeed rare. In this case, you can start reverse engineering your proprietary file format using an executable file that can parse this particular format. But how can you find this executable file?

There are two options:

Option 1: Find an executable file by the signature of the target file.

Scan the entire program catalog that works with the file you plan to reverse engineer, searching for the signature in binary form. Launch a search by file contents to find a signature that matches your target file. Look for the bytes the target file begins with using specialized tools like Effective File Search or Total Commander for Windows or a command-line tool like grep or Binwalk on Linux and macOS respectively.

If you manage to find a matching signature, load the executable file into the interactive disassembler (IDA), search where the file signature is checked, and start reversing the code that performs further parsing of data.

If a file doesn’t have a signature or you don’t find anything when searching by file contents, you can analyze the file at runtime.

Option 2: Analyze the target file at runtime.

Launch the Process Monitor, set a filter for file operations, and try to catch the moment when the proprietary file is opened. Then, look at the relevant row in the Process Monitor to find a CreateFile operation or the first ReadFile for your file. Look at the Stack of this event to see which executable file attempted to call ReadFile() and, what’s more important, what the address is in the code. Upload your file to IDA and see how the parsing runs, just like with signature search.

Quite often, the code for parsing is located close to the place where reading starts. In such a case, look at all the ReadFile operations, see how many bytes are read, and see where these bytes are located in the file.

However, some files can be developed in a more complicated way. For example, a developer could have used classes of streams or even custom classes to access files based on the hierarchy of classes with virtual functions and multithreading instead of using simple functions for reading files.

In such cases, when you find the ReadFile function, you won’t find any parsing code close to it. All you’ll see is a ReadFile that’s called from some virtual function, and the read data will be stored in a buffer.

In this scenario, you’ll have to:

  1. Recover the class of the reader
  2. Find the class that uses the reader to receive data from the buffer
  3. Understand how that class synchronizes with the reader

Only then can you find the class that parses the data from your file.

However, sometimes you might need to recover data from a file having neither a signature nor an executable file. Let’s explore what can be done in such cases.

Read also:
The Evolution of Reverse Engineering: From Manual Reconstruction to Automated Disassembling

How to reverse engineer a data format without an executable file

Before we start exploring an example of how to recover data from a proprietary file format without an executable file, let’s briefly overview the general logic of how information is stored in a file.

It’s important to understand that all files have structured data. No one creates file formats in a way that allows for randomly placing objects.

Every file format has a certain logic. And this logic is usually related to the file’s purpose. For example, files of filesystem images must have specific structures to be able to store metadata such as size, name, and other attributes. Image files must be able to store information about an image’s size, the number of colors, and other image metadata.

Developers usually have limited options for organizing information storage in a file they create. The choice of logic is usually based on the developer’s knowledge and experience. There’s no need to overcomplicate such a task and try to come up with original ideas, especially when creating a proprietary file format.

Now let’s explore how to reverse engineer a proprietary data file format using a real-life example. Here we have a random firmware file in a closed format. We can’t find any information on the internet based on its signature, and it doesn’t have a distinct extension that can help us identify the format.

1 firmware file in a folder

Screenshot 1. A firmware file in a folder

Apparently the data is in the largest file: swfl_00005684.bin.001_032_079. But we also can see the swfl_00005684.xml.001_032_079 file, which can be useful for uncovering how to parse data from the target file.

The first rule is don’t neglect metadata.

In this case, we see an XML file near the file we want to recover. Once we open the swfl_00005684.xml.001_032_079 file, we discover a description of the BIN file parts:


  
    swfl_00005684_0042A00
    0000000
    00001FF
    0042A00
    0042BFF
    UNKNOWN
    371E
  
  
    swfl_00005684_0115000
    0000200
    00005CD
    0115000
    01153CD
    UNKNOWN
    0D73
  
  
    swfl_00005684_0F15000
    00005CE
    043BA91
    0F15000
    13504C3
    UNKNOWN
    EE1F
  

In this example, SOURCE-START-ADDRESS points to the beginning of the fragment that offsets in the BIN file. And SOURCE-END-ADDRESS is the end of this fragment.

Read also:
9 Best Reverse Engineering Tools for 2021 [Updated]

After extracting data fragments from the swfl_00005684.bin.001_032_079 file, as described in the XML file, we get three files. One of them is a digital signature, and the other two have another proprietary format with the HAR#$%&@ signature.

We find out that these two files are archives. The first clue is that Data Visualizer shows us that the files have a little text in the beginning and then have high-entropy data.

2 how high entropy data looks in the data visualizer

Screenshot 2. How high-entropy data looks in the Data Visualizer

The second clue is how this file looks in a hex editor:

3 how the beginning of a har file looks in a hex editor

Screenshot 3. How the beginning of a HAR file looks in a hex editor

It looks like a table with the names of files from an archive. However, the challenge is to find a way to parse this data so we can connect zlib streams with their metadata.

Since we understood it’s information about files in the archive, we paste this data into Notepad to see which data is changing and which is not. Here’s what we end up with:

4 how data from HAR file header looks in notepad

Screenshot 4. How data from a HAR file header looks in Notepad

Therefore, there are high chances that the file’s metadata saved in an archive will contain information like create/update dates, attributes, and the size of compressed and decompressed files.

Information about create/update dates will vary a little for different files within the archive, because the file metadata is usually presented in Unix Time format. This is why we can see that this data is mostly repeated.

The second rule we can learn working with this file is to know how common data types look in the hex editor. By common data types, we mean Unix Time, Dos Time, Float, Double, etc.

It’s obvious that if metadata contains a catalog description (not a file), it won’t have sizes mentioned.

After the directories, we have an entry as shown in the screenshot below. Since it’s a file descriptor, this entry has the size fields filled with values.

5 entry we get after directories

Screenshot 5. Entry we get after directories

For the sake of curiosity, we use the Offzip scanning tool to confirm our guess, and here’s the result:

6 the result of the offzip tool after scanning the har file

Screenshot 6. The result of the Offzip tool after scanning the HAR file

Let’s see the data we have at the end of the HAR file at offset 0x335:

7 data at the end of the har file at offset 0x335

Screenshot 7. Data at the end of the HAR file at offset 0x335

It’s a zlib stream at offset 0x335 which has the length of 0x99 bytes.

These are the same digits we’ve already seen in the metadata. So we can conclude that this HAR file only contains the /tmp/manifest/usr/share/swe/00005684/00f15000.manifest file, and the rest are catalogs.

So, we extracted a file of unknown format only using data from the file itself because we understood what we expected to find there.

Read also:
How to Reverse Engineer an iOS App and macOS Software

Conclusion

Knowing how to reverse engineer a proprietary file format can help you ensure your software works with a wide variety of file formats.

But reverse engineering a closed file format is challenging. It requires not only expert skills in reverse engineering but also deep knowledge in lots of other topics. For example, it’s essential to pay attention to other files that are stored near the one you need to reverse engineer and know what different data types look like in a hex editor.

At Apriorit, we have experienced teams of reverse engineers who can help you with the most complex reverse engineering tasks. Apart from working with closed file formats, our expertise includes researching malware, searching for vulnerabilities in embedded software, analyzing for intellectual property rights violations, as well as supporting and patching undocumented code.

Need expert skills in reverse engineering to improve your software’s interoperability and security? Contact us to discuss your needs and find the best solutions together!

Recommended for you
White Paper

Reverse Engineering in the IT Project Lifecycle

Tell us about your project
Send us a request for proposal! We’ll get back to you with details and estimations.

Browse
By clicking Send you give consent to processing your data

Book an Exploratory Call

Do not have any specific task for us in mind but our skills seem interesting?

Get a quick Apriorit intro to better understand our team capabilities.

Contact Us

  • +1 202-780-9339
  • [email protected]
  • 3524 Silverside Road Suite 35B Wilmington, DE 19810-4929 United States
  • D-U-N-S number: 117063762